1994 (0-2)
lost to Central (Iowa), 6-0 [Central was defending champion]
lost to Simpson, 5-0

1996 (0-2)
lost to Chapman, 3-0 [Chapman was defending champion and went on to finish second in 1996]
lost to Calvin, 5-0

2000 (2-2)
defeated Anderson, 6-4
lost to Muskingum, 4-2
defeated Wittenberg, 5-4
lost to Anderson, 5-4

2001 (3-2)
defeated U. of Chicago, 4-3
lost to North Central, 9-4
defeated Carroll, 6-3
defeated North Central, 10-2
lost to North Central, 5-2

2002 (1-2)
lost to Washington U., 4-1
defeated Eureka, 8-3
lost to Webster, 9-6

2003 - Third place, NCAA Division III (5-2)
defeated Wisconsin-Whitewater, 2-1
defeated U. of Chicago, 4-2
defeated U. of Chicago, 3-2 (11 inn.) - Regional Championship
defeated Muskingum, 9-2
defeated Emory, 1-0 (8 inn.)
lost to Salisbury State, 5-3 (10 inn.)
lost to Central (Iowa), 8-3 [Central won national championship next day]

2007 (1-2)
defeated St. Norbert, 8-6
lost to Wisconsin-Eau Claire, 3-0
lost to Coe College, 5-1

2008 (1-2)
lost to Simpson, 1-0
defeated Ripon, 3-0
lost to Wisconsin-Oshkosh, 1-0